The proper response for a Christian in the days after a contentious election is renewed commitment to building up the Body of Christ. This is true whether the results provide an occasion for joyful expectation or gut-wrenching despair. Political matters are important, especially in a democracy, but they are not to be treated as first things. Indeed, the test of whether one is doing politics rightly is its relative unimportance in one’s life. One should be able to rattle off a healthy list of greater priorities, such as one’s relationship to God, family, and friends.
This is not to say that politics is insignificant or that it doesn’t at times require urgent attention. Nor am I doubting that the Church has a vital role to play in the nation’s political wranglings. Indeed, it is the mission of First Things to bring matters of first importance to bear on political discourse. Christians have essential contributions to make, and religious people of all types must struggle against any attempt to build a “naked public square.” This does not mean, of course, that those professing the same religion will agree politically.
We are living through a highly polarized political moment. The lopsidedness of the Democratic victory in the midterm elections does not, in all likelihood, signal an ideological shift on the part of the citizenry, but rather an expression of profound dissatisfaction with the policy choices and priorities of the Trump administration. Moreover, as I have noted in a previous newsletter, American elections are binary choices. If you are unhappy with the Republicans, you vote for the Democrats, and vice versa. While R. R. Reno is perhaps right that the election reflects widespread dissatisfaction with the status quo of American politics, there is little reason to expect polarization to wane as Democrats take control of Congress. The only difference is that it will not be only Trump’s inflammatory rhetoric and radical policy proposals making the news.
The question arises, therefore, of how Catholics, both lay and clerical, should speak in this new and perilous moment. I was pleased, and a bit surprised, to find that Gaudium et Spes, the Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the Modern World, provides some guidance. Its fourth chapter, entitled “The Life of the Political Community,” opens by affirming the right of “citizens, individually or collectively” to “take an active part in the life and government of the state” as well as the rights of association and expression enabling that participation. Since disputes over policy are inevitable, the council fathers insist on the right of individuals and groups to “to prefer divergent solutions.” They insist, however, that disagreements, like all of political life, ought to foster “an inward sense of justice and kindliness, and of service to the common good.” In this, Christians ought to lead the way:
All Christians must be aware of their own specific vocation within the political community. It is for them to give an example by their sense of responsibility and their service of the common good. In this way they are to demonstrate concretely how authority can be compatible with freedom, personal initiative with the solidarity of the whole social organism, and the advantages of unity with fruitful diversity. They must recognize the legitimacy of different opinions with regard to temporal solutions, and respect citizens, who, even as a group, defend their points of view by honest methods. (GS 75)
It strikes me that this teaching is particularly relevant for American Catholics, of the left and of the right, in our present situation.

